The Debate on Civil War Monuments. Names are being scrubbed from institutions. Removing the Civil War monument from the northern corner of Florida’s Historic Capitol — or leaving it there — is not as simple as it may sound. Our silent Civil War: Debate over statues didn't come out of thin air In history, suppressed memories, stories half-told or lied about, carry greater power for having been suppressed While the private monument remains, there is renewed debate about whether a bust of General Forrest in the State Capitol Building (public property) should be retained. The momentum to remove Confederate memorials … Most respondents in a new poll by Winthrop University want to do something about the monuments, but they don’t agree on what. The Confederacy lost the Civil War, but it certainly won the battle to memorialize the conflict and in the process recast the war as "a noble lost cause." Reply Link. And I hope they meet the same fate. ... South Carolina monuments. ... a glorification of the “Old South” and a reimagining of the Civil War as a heroic effort that … Removing the Civil War monument from the northern corner of Florida’s Historic Capitol — or leaving it there — is not as simple as it may sound. White supremacists, neo-Nazis and others have protested the removal of Confederate monuments. The Civil War may be 150-year-old history, but the work on many Confederate monuments and commemorations is surprisingly recent. But the Confederate general Robert E. Lee himself never wanted such monuments built. Now that you've read the … Under the government speech doctrine, the government can display or not display certain monuments. Civil War monuments bear a constant testimony to all of this history, none of which should be forgotten. More than 30 cities across the United States have removed or relocated Confederate statues and monuments amid an intense nationwide debate about race and history. 65th NY Guy Feb 21, 2021 @ 4:15. Confederate Monument Debate Returns to Dallas City Hall Monument remained through nearly 2 years of delay on what to do with it ... keep the monument and add context about the civil war or do nothing. Perhaps it is their ubiquity that has allowed Confederate monuments to stand for so long ( by one count, about 1,500 in 31 states ) In 1957, dressed in civil war-era clothing, Mrs Lonnie Holley, her daughter Janalee and Mrs Benjamin T Whitfield place a wreath at a Mississippi monument … Since New Orleans dismantled its Confederate monuments in 2017, and as other communities North and South continue to reckon with Civil War symbolism, faced with often stark divisions in opinion as well as the bureaucratic structures keeping it in place, there has been much public debate about the need for an antidote to monumental permanence. The debate about Civil War monuments is not about the history of the Civil War, but about how it is remembered and commemorated. Off to the relics room. In Tennessee, for example, there is a debate about whether to remove the bust of General Nathan Bedford Forrest from the state capital. Civil War Round Table to debate the removal of Southern monuments Mar 4, 2020 admin DOVER - The Tuscarawas Valley Civil War Round Table meet March 12th at 7:00 p.m. at the Dover Public Library, where former Presidents John Fazio and Mel Maurer present, "Opposing Viewpoints on the Removal of Southern Civil War Related Symbols and Monuments." Civil War Monuments Monuments and the Spaces They Occupy Monument and Memorials: Memorial for Confederate Pensioners of Color Alexander County Confederate Monument, Taylorsville Inscription Front, bronze: THE YOUNG MAN WHO ADORNS THIS PEDESTAL / WAS KILLED AT GETTYSBURG, JULY3, 1863. The prevalence of Confederate monuments is in large measure due to the efforts of the United Confederate Veterans, the United Daughters of the Confederacy, and the Sons of Confederate Veterans. The Iowa Division of … Well said. Many municipalities in the United States have removed monuments and memorials on public property dedicated to the Confederate States of America (CSA), and some, such as Silent Sam in North Carolina, have been torn down by protestors. The first Confederate statue on Monument Avenue wasn't built until 1890, 25 years after the Civil War ended. The last one went up in 1929. Here is a … SUBSCRIBE NOW $3 for 3 months. The values these monuments stood for, he says, included a “glorification of the cause of the Civil War.” White women were instrumental in raising funds to build these Confederate monuments. This is an important distinction when it comes to this issue. In 1938, elderly Civil War veterans gathered in Gettysburg in the spirit of reconciliation to dedicate the Eternal Light Peace Memorial. The American Civil War Miller School of Albemarle Senior Capstone Class. The structure — a wall designed by Maya Lin, containing the names of every service member known to be killed in the Vietnam War — is situated within an extensive complex of monuments … The debate over controversial statues and monuments. A vast majority of these monuments, markers and tablets denote Civil War units, rather than individual military figures. In the civil rights era, segregationists again sought to … Reply Link. Even so, Confederate monuments would not exist in such large numbers without mass production, which, in the wake of the Civil War, was far more possible in the North rather than in the South. Removal of Confederate monuments and memorials is an ongoing process in the United States since the 1960s. As monuments went up, so did the bodies of black men, women and children during a long rash of lynching. Menu. The fierce resistance when Confederate monuments are in question stands as a reminder of the issues at stake in the Civil War, and the ways in which they … Forrest was a cavalry commander during the war, but he also helped found the Ku Klux Klan. Dr. Gary Gallagher Discusses Civil War Monuments. https://www.c-span.org/video/?448679-5/debate-confederate-monuments COLUMBIA, S.C. – Residents in the South are split on what to do with controversial monuments to Civil War and segregation-era figures. The Empirical Side of the Monuments Debate. The nearly 1,800 monuments, ... Due process and honest debate over altering town squares remain vital. The monuments should remain, and we should constantly remind ourselves of … Civil War Monuments in Washington, D.C., includes monuments to 16 Union generals, admirals and others Lincoln Statue by sculptor Lot Flannery, 1868; Abraham Lincoln by Vinnie Ream, located in the Capitol Rotunda, 1871; General John A. Rawlins, Joseph A. Bailly, sculptor, 1874; Brevet Lt. General Winfield Scott, Henry Kirke Brown, sculptor, 1874; Emancipation Memorial, Thomas Ball, sculptor, 1876 So far, we have catalogued over 4,000 Civil War-era monuments and memorial designations across the United States. How did the debate about Confederate monuments begin? Here’s a line easy to draw: Those Civil War figures who engaged in postwar domestic terrorism? Push To Remove Confederate Monuments Opens Debate On Other Honored Historical Figures Statues have been taken down. ... "We essentially want to cancel these Civil War generals and monuments, which I think is a … More than 2,100 of these come from the Union side of the Civil War, plus an additional 160 abolitionist statues and commemorations. History should inform debate over Civil War monuments | … The national debate over the monuments’ future is not unlike what happened in Prague and other cities at the end of the Cold War. In the Former Capital of the Confederacy, the Debate Over the City’s Famed Civil War Monuments Heats Up By Jaweed Kaleem Sunday, August 20, 2017 at 3:36 pm | כ"ח אב תשע"ז